Right Up There with the Taoist Classic "C Is For Cookie-- Is Good Enough for Me"

Female voice over speakerphone: Maybe you shouldn't listen to me. I just reached into my glass of milk to retrieve a cookie that I accidentally dropped to the bottom during dunking. Now I am covered in milk. I've got milk hands!
Fraternity guy: I thought you were trying to make your own metaphor, like "I don't see the glass as half empty or half full, I see my hand in it retrieving cookies."

Providence, Rhode Island

Overheard by: Wants No Part Of This